Our Fault (2025) Movie ft. Nicole, Gabriela, Gabriel

Our Fault brings the Culpables trilogy to a close with Nicole Wallace and Gabriel Guevara back as Noah and Nick. The film hit Prime Video on October 16, 2025, directed by Domingo González who also wrote the script with Sofía Cuenca. This Spanish romance adapts Mercedes Ron’s Wattpad novels, which have found a massive global following.

The production wrapped filming alongside Your Fault in early 2024, keeping the same visual style throughout both films. Pokeepsie Films handled production, maintaining the glossy aesthetic fans expect from this series. The cast includes returning players like Gabriela Andrada and Marta Hazas, plus some fresh faces.

Four Years Later

The story jumps ahead four years from where Your Fault ended. Noah and Nick split up and went their separate ways. Now they’re forced back together at Lion and Jenna’s wedding. Nick runs his grandfather’s business empire, while Noah has started building her own career path.

Their reunion isn’t smooth. Nick hasn’t forgiven Noah for what happened between them. She’s not sure reopening old wounds makes sense anymore. But weddings have a way of bringing people together whether they want it or not.

The Central Question

The film explores whether their feelings outweigh the damage they caused each other. Nick’s resentment creates barriers that seem impossible to cross. Both resist falling back into patterns that destroyed them before. Time hasn’t healed everything—in some ways, distance made things worse.

I watched these characters navigate conversations loaded with history. Every interaction carries weight from their past. The question hanging over everything: have they grown enough to make different choices, or will they repeat the same mistakes?

Cast Dynamics

Wallace and Guevara’s chemistry remains strong. They understand these characters after playing them across three films. Wallace shows Noah’s growth without losing her vulnerability. She handles emotional scenes well, finding moments of genuine connection within the drama.

Guevara brings complexity to Nick’s anger. He’s not just bitter—he’s hurt and struggling with unresolved feelings. The performance works when he tones down the theatricality. Supporting actors like Andrada and Hazas contribute solid work, though the script keeps them mostly on the sidelines.

Strengths

The film delivers what its audience wants. Beautiful Spanish locations, attractive leads, expensive-looking production design. Everything feels polished and intentional. I can appreciate the commitment to giving fans the closure they’ve been waiting for through three installments.

The cinematography captures romantic moments effectively. Wide shots of wedding venues and intimate close-ups during confrontations work together to create visual interest. Production values stay high throughout, never looking cheap or rushed despite the back-to-back filming schedule.

Weaknesses

The script hits familiar beats without adding anything new. Characters circle the same issues repeatedly. Conflicts arise from misunderstandings that could be cleared up with simple conversations. Dialogue often sounds unnatural, with people delivering speeches rather than talking like real humans would.

Pacing becomes an issue around the middle section. Scenes stretch longer than necessary without developing character or advancing plot. I found myself checking how much time remained. Supporting storylines get introduced then abandoned or resolved too quickly to matter. The film rushes through emotional payoffs that needed more space to breathe.

Critical Divide

Professional reviewers haven’t embraced this trilogy. FilmAffinity awarded 2 out of 5 stars, describing it as bland and predictable. My Fault received 0% on Rotten Tomatoes from critics, while Your Fault got 20%. The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw called these films wooden and bizarre, comparing them unfavorably to soap operas.

Audience response tells another story entirely. My Fault scored 86% with viewers despite zero critical approval. All three films dominated streaming charts globally. The books’ massive fanbase translated directly into viewership, proving critics and audiences value completely different things.

Understanding Both Sides

This disconnect makes sense when you examine what each group prioritizes. Reviewers want sophisticated storytelling and layered character development. Fans want romantic escapism with passionate moments and attractive people. Both perspectives are valid—they’re just measuring success differently.

I see merit in both viewpoints. The trilogy delivers exactly what it promises. But it also shows the challenges of adapting internet fiction that thrives on heightened emotion and fantasy fulfillment. What works on Wattpad doesn’t always translate to screen without feeling excessive.

Bottom Line

Our Fault wraps up the trilogy competently without breaking new ground. It satisfies invested viewers while confirming critics’ concerns about these adaptations. The film knows its target demographic and serves them specifically, providing closure fans have wanted since My Fault premiered in 2023.

It lacks depth that might broaden its appeal beyond existing fans. Performances are earnest but limited by overwrought writing. Direction stays safe when bold choices might have created something memorable. The result feels well-crafted but disposable unless you’re already emotionally invested in Noah and Nick.

Rating: 2.5 out of 5